Search the database

8 case files

French AvenueLiquid Brun
SC-0001

French Avenue

Liquid Brun

Upheld

Target: Althaïr · Parfums de Marly

$33$290Saves 89%

Rough, medicinal first ten minutes — the 'opening tax'. Performance is split: most owners get rich hours, a minority gets about four weak ones. Batch variance is real.

Strong evidence · 1,500 reviewsSmells expensive
Al HaramainDétour Noir
SC-0002

Al Haramain

Détour Noir

Verified

Target: Layton · Parfums de Marly

$25$290Saves 91%

A medicinal, Vicks-like camphor/plastic opening — and a famously cheap-looking bottle.

Strong evidence · 2,688 reviewsSmells expensive
LattafaAsad
SC-0009

Lattafa

Asad

Contested

Target: Sauvage Elixir · Dior

$28$195Saves 86%

Denser and more synthetic than the Dior, and newer buyers now put the match closer to 60–75%. Longevity reports swing widely.

Strong evidence · 1,500 reviewsValue beast
AfnanSupremacy Collector's Edition
SC-0011

Afnan

Supremacy Collector's Edition

Verified

Target: Aventus Absolu · Creed

$45$500Saves 91%

Named across many videos, but the corpus holds only a handful of distinct owner opinions — and newer 2026 batches draw weaker-performance complaints (some report ~5 hours, or about an hour of strong projection).

Developing evidence · ~5 community reportsSmells expensive
RayhaanNocturno Elixir
SC-0015

Rayhaan

Nocturno Elixir

Contested

Target: Bleu de Chanel Parfum · Chanel

$30$180Saves 83%

It reads high-end in the air but the room splits on skin — a vocal minority gets a 'poopy shower gel' animalic edge.

Developing evidence · ~4 community reportsCoin flip
LattafaKhamrah Qahwa
SC-0067

Lattafa

Khamrah Qahwa

Verified

Target: Angel's Share · By Kilian

$35$300Saves 88%

Headache-inducing sweetness for some, and the coffee note is reported as light or inconsistent. As an Angel's Share 'clone' the match is only 50–70%.

Moderate evidence · 1,521 reviewsVery sweet
Maison AlhambraTobacco Touch
SC-0021

Maison Alhambra

Tobacco Touch

Contested

Target: Tobacco Vanille · Tom Ford

$25$295Saves 92%

The opening is repeatedly called harsh, clovey or medicinal — it disappoints anyone sold it as a universally safe winter vanilla.

Moderate evidence · ~7 community reportsSample first
Al HaramainAmber Oud Gold Edition
SC-0058B

Al Haramain

Amber Oud Gold Edition

Verified

Target: Erba Pura · Xerjoff

$60$300Saves 80%

Polarizing oversweetness — it turns cloying or headache-inducing fast if you overspray. Two sprays is the ceiling.

Moderate evidence · ~5 community reportsVery sweet