Case SC-0001 · Today's case
The internet hyped it.
We checked the evidence.
Search fragrance dupes, compare the claims, and see what survives real wear.
French Avenue
Liquid Brun
Target: Althaïr · Parfums de Marly
“Smells expensive.” / “Harsh and synthetic up top.”
Strong evidence · 1,500 reviewsRough, medicinal first ten minutes — the 'opening tax'. Performance is split: most owners get rich hours, a minority gets about four weak ones. Batch variance is real.
Armaf
Club de Nuit Intense Man
Target: Aventus · Creed
It's a batch lottery — some bottles last twelve hours, some die in two — and the opening gets called lemon floor cleaner or burnt rubber.
Al Haramain
Détour Noir
Target: Layton · Parfums de Marly
A medicinal, Vicks-like camphor/plastic opening — and a famously cheap-looking bottle.
Afnan
Turathi Blue
Target: Tygar · Bvlgari
The drydown drifts from the real Tygar, and a vocal camp calls it an 'old person's bathroom refreshener'.
Lattafa
Asad
Target: Sauvage Elixir · Dior
Denser and more synthetic than the Dior, and newer buyers now put the match closer to 60–75%. Longevity reports swing widely.
We do not ask you to trust one nose.
We show you where the evidence agrees — and where it does not.
Read the standardsCreator claims
Separated out and never treated as proof.
Owner experience
Long-term wear reports, weighted by sample size.
Skeptical pushback
Kept visible instead of averaged away.
The ruling
Consensus, disagreement, performance range, use-case fit.
- Verdict: WaitAfnan 9PM Night Out2h ago
- Contested · don't overpayLattafa Al Qiam Silver6h ago
- Batch lottery flaggedArmaf Club de Nuit Intense1d ago
- BlacklistedLattafa Asad Zanzibar1d ago
- Verdict upheld on appealFrench Avenue Liquid Brun2d ago
- ContestedRayhaan Nocturno Elixir3d ago
- Re-trial pendingJean Lowe Fantasme5d ago
Nocturno Elixir enters Contested — the $30 'boss blue' that splits on skin
It reads high-end in the air; a vocal minority gets a 'poopy shower gel' edge. Test on skin before you commit.
BlacklistAsad Zanzibar goes on the blacklist
'Worst Asad ever', 'industrial cleaning product', 'I almost vomit'. The negative evidence is one-sided.
Don't overpayAl Qiam Silver is just Turathi Blue with a Tygar story
Sold as a Bvlgari Tygar dupe; the match is weak and it's near-identical to Turathi at the same price.
Build your Scent Court shelf
Save bottles, follow contested cases, and get notified when new evidence changes a ruling. The database is public. Accounts — saving, alerts and personalization — are launching soon.
Create a free account · Coming soon